Hutchins won the tiebreaker over Lindenman as Simpson's varsity team fired a 312 to win the one-round tournament.
Originally scheduled to take place April 2, inclement weather pushed the tournament to Wednesday.
Simpson shot 312, followed by Simpson's junior varstiy (329), Coe (330) and Coe's junior varsity (389).
Hutchins finished the day strong, making birdie on 13 and 15 at a windy Indianola Country Club. His birdie on 13 gave him the win over Lindenman, who shot a five on the second handicap hole. Both players carded a five on the first handicap hole, No. 3.
Hutchins trailed Lindenman by two strokes on the front nine but fired a 36 on the back for his lowest round of the spring.
The reigning Iowa Conference Golfer of the Week, Lindenman made three birdies on the day, shooting 36 on the front nine and 38 on the back.
Jimmy Siebert led Simpson's second team with a 77, placing third overall. He matched his lowest round of the spring, making birdie on the par-five fifth.
Simpson travels to Storm Lake this weekend for the Buena Vista Invitational.